Blessed

Matthew 5:1-12

Blessed.

When is the last time someone blessed you?  I don’t mean the hasty “bless you” that we say when someone sneezes or the “well bless your heart” people sometimes say in a way that sounds like what they’re really saying is “well aren’t you a curious little specimen.”

When is the last time that someone spoke a real blessing upon you?

When is the last time you felt like someone had spoken a powerful and prophetic word to tell you that you matter and that you live in the heart of goodness…

When is the last time that someone told you

that you are consecrated…

that your life is sacred…

that you are holy?

When is the last time someone told you that God sees you and loves you even when you’re not feeling it?  Especially when you’re not feeling it?

When is the last time you spoke that kind of blessing for someone else?

Jesus had been travelling all over the region healing people and  proclaiming the reign of heaven.  Large crowds had started to follow him.  People came from all over to see him and hear him and be healed by him.  And maybe, just maybe, to be blessed by him.

Jesus went up the hill to a place where he could see out over the crowd and where they could see and hear him.  His disciples came and sat close to him.  Jesus looked at his rag-tag followers, he looked out over the crowd, and he could see them all.  He could see who they were and what they were.

He saw how life had broken them.  He saw their longing to be made whole again.  He saw their yearning to be told that their lives mattered, that their struggles mattered, that their pain mattered.  He wasn’t recruiting followers, he was just meeting people in the everyday reality of their lives and telling them the truth about themselves.   Just like he does for us.

He told them who they were, but he also told them who they could be.  His words were not just descriptive, they were transformative.  Just like they are for us.

He looked out at them and told them they were blessed.  Just like he tells us.

Blessed are the poor in spirit.  Blessed are those who doubt.  Blessed are those who struggle with believing and trusting.  Blessed are those who wonder if they have enough faith.  Blessed are those who feel spiritually malnourished and spiritually drained.  Blessed are those who are running on empty.  Blessed are those who feel like they have nothing to give.  Blessed are those who are far from certain about who God is and what God does and how it all works.  Blessed are those who find all the old answers unsatisfactory or troubling.  Blessed are those whose minds and hearts are open to new information, new ways of seeing and new ways of thinking.  Blessed are those who sometimes feel lost in the mystery of it all.  Blessed are the poor in spirit.  They shall see things others do not see.  They will ask questions others do not dare to ask.  They will use their imaginations in ways that others find daunting.  Blessed are the poor in spirit.  God sees them.  God walks with them.  Even when they can’t see it or feel it, heaven is all around them and within them.  And they are blessed.

Blessed are those who mourn.  Blessed are those for whom grief is an overwhelming reality.  Blessed are those whose lives have been hollowed out by loss.  Blessed are those who live in the shadow  of death.  Blessed are those who weep.  Blessed are those whose tears have dried up but whose pain has not.  Blessed are those who have learned the hard way that grief is love persevering.  Blessed are the brokenhearted.  Blessed are those who are crumbling inside but hold themselves together to keep everyone around them from falling apart.  Blessed are those who mourn.  Their tears are sacred.  God carries their pain and draws close to them.  Blessed are those who mourn.  They will be comforted.

Blessed are the gentle, the meek, the nonviolent.  Blessed are those who look for ways to compromise and cooperate instead of making life a contest or a competition.  Blessed are the strong who restrain themselves. Blessed are those who do not fight back, those who would rather take it than dish it out. Blessed are those who go unnoticed, the ones who sit alone at lunch, the unimpressive, the unemployed.  Blessed are the janitors and sanitation workers and fast food workers.  Blessed are those who struggle with the rent.  Blessed are the people on the street whom we fail to see because we pretend they are invisible.  Blessed are the meek.  God sees them.  God loves them.  The earth is theirs.

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness.  Blessed are those who were born with an acute sense of what is fair and what is not, what is right and what is not.  Blessed are those who have a passion for justice.  Blessed are those who work to overcome injustice even when the injustice has nothing to do with them or their lives.  Blessed are those who are wrongly accused.  Blessed are the undocumented.   Blessed are those who stand against the bullies.  Blessed are those who confront racism and work to dismantle it.  Blessed are those who march in the streets and speak truth to power.  Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness. God sees them.  God loves them.  God will nourish them with justice and their cup will be filled.

Blessed are the merciful.  Blessed are those who fill the world around them with kindness.  Blessed are those who are generous with forgiveness.  Blessed are those who are just plain generous.  Blessed are those who are slow to judge and condemn because they understand how much they have been forgiven.  Blessed are the merciful.  God sees them.  God loves them.  They will receive mercy.

Blessed are the pure in heart.  Blessed are those who have retained their innocence and are just plain good.  Blessed are those who have recovered their innocence and cling to it.  Blessed are the honest.  Blessed are the truthful.  Blessed are those who love with no agenda.  Blessed are those who are in recovery, who are living out the twelve steps, who are cleansing their bodies and their souls and making amends. Blessed are those who refuse to be cynical.  Blessed are the pure in heart.  God loves them.  God sees them.  And they shall see God.

Blessed are the peacemakers.  Blessed are those who bring food to those who are starving.  Blessed are those who bring medical attention to those who are in peril.  Blessed are those who work to disarm a weaponized world.  Blessed are those who encourage us to seek common ground.  Blessed are those who care for the planet and work to heal the earth.  Blessed are the peacemakers.  God embraces them as God’s own children.

Blessed are those who are persecuted for doing the right thing.  Blessed are those who are disrespected and taunted for being compassionate.  Blessed are the woke.  Blessed are those who are scorned because they speak out for a better world and work for the shalom of God.  Blessed those who are battered or imprisoned because they protest against all the things that dehumanize people and oppress people.  Blessed are those who are persecuted for doing the right thing.  The kingdom of heaven is theirs.

Blessed are you when people revile you and persecute you and say all kinds of untrue and evil things against you because you have embraced the Way, the Truth and the Life.  Blessed are you when people spread lies about you because your integrity exposes their duplicity.  Blessed are you when people criticize you for being awake to the pain and injustice around you.  If you only knew how great your reward is in heaven, you would be dancing with joy.  God sees you.  God loves you.  And remember, they persecuted the prophets in the same way, so you are in good company.

You are blessed.

You are consecrated.

You are holy.

You are set apart to bring a blessing and to be a blessing in a world that thinks it is cursed.

You are consecrated to help others see the beauty and sacredness of our life together in this amazing God-made, God-filled world.

With all your faults—and God knows them better than you know them yourself—you are loved by God more than you can begin to imagine so that you can spread the love of God to others.

God is blessing you.  God is loving you.  God is transforming you.

You live in the heart of goodness.

Blessed are you.

In Jesus’ name.

Out of Love for the Truth

John 8:31-36

“Out of love for the truth and from a desire to elucidate it, the Reverend Father Martin Luther, Master of Arts and Sacred Theology, and ordinary lecturer therein at Wittenberg, intends to defend the following statements and to dispute on them in that place.  Therefore he asks that those who cannot be present and dispute with him orally shall do so in their absence by letter.  In the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, Amen.”

This was the introduction to the 95 Theses which Martin Luther nailed to the door of the Wittenberg University Chapel on Wednesday, October 31, 1517.   We sometimes think that nailing the 95 Theses to the door of the church was an act of rebellion, and in retrospect it was powerfully symbolic, but it was actually a normal practice.  The church door served as a kind of bulletin board for the academic community.  If you wanted to propose a debate, that’s where you posted the notice, along with the propositions you wanted to discuss.

Luther didn’t intend for the 95 Theses to be a manifesto for rebellion.  He had no idea that his challenge to the practice of selling indulgences would spark a revolutionary movement that would sweep across Europe leading to enormous changes in religion, politics, education, and everyday life, but once that movement started, he gave himself to it body and soul because he was committed to the truth of the Gospel and the love of Christ.

The truth quite literally set him free from the heavy-handed authority of Rome—the Pope excommunicated him—but the truth also bound him to the proclamation of salvation by God’s grace through faith and to the authority of God’s word in the scriptures.

Out of love for the truth and from a desire to elucidate it…

According to the Gospel of John, when Jesus was on trial before Pontius Pilate, Pilate then asked him, “What is truth?”

In some respects that seems like an almost ridiculous question.  We know what truth is.  We learn about truth almost as soon as we learn to talk.  Sadly, that’s also when we learn to lie, because we learn pretty quickly that the truth may reveal things that we would prefer to keep hidden.  We learn very early on that sometimes truth has consequences that we would like to avoid, and that those consequences might be unpleasant or even painful.

Truth, the dictionary tells us, is the true or actual state of a matter.  Something is true when it conforms with reality.  To put it another way, reality determines what is true.

Truth means that my desires or imagination do not have the final word in determining what reality is and what it is not.

There are twenty-seven verses in the gospels that contain the word truth.  Twenty-one of those verses are in the Gospel of John where truth is not only a central theme, it is anchored in and identified with the person of Jesus.  In John 1:14 we read, “the Word became flesh and lived among us, and we have seen his glory, the glory as of a father’s only son, full of grace and truth.”  Three verses later, John puts aside the figurative language of the Word to make it clear who he is talking about: “The law indeed was given through Moses; grace and truth came through Jesus Christ.”

When Jesus sat discussing theology with the Samaritan Woman at Jacob’s Well, he told her that “true worshipers will worship the Father in spirit and truth.”  In chapter 14, not long after he has told Thomas that he, himself, is “the way, the truth, and the life,” Jesus refers to the Holy Spirit as “the Spirit of truth” and in chapter 16 he tells his disciples that “when the Spirit of truth comes, he will guide you into all the truth.”  In chapter 17, as he prays for the disciples, Jesus asks that they would be sanctified and consecrated in truth.

“For this I was born,” Jesus told Pilate, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth.  Everyone who belongs to the truth listens to my voice.”

In today’s Gospel reading from chapter 8 of John’s gospel, we see a hint that some of those who were listening to Jesus were unsure about continuing to follow him.  Some scholars think that this passage may hint at some tension between Jewish and Gentile believers or between Judean and Galilean followers of Jesus in the community where this gospel was written, and John, the writer, is calling both sides back to the middle ground of the truth they had found in the person and teaching of Jesus.

“Jesus said to the Judeans who had believed in him, ‘If you continue in my word—if you remain faithful to my teachings—then you are truly my disciples.  And you will come to know the truth.  And the truth will set you free.”  When they protested that they were descendants of Abraham and had never been enslaved by anyone—apparently they forgot about their own history with Babylon and Egypt—Jesus went on to make it clear that he was talking about the truth setting them—and us—free from our slavery to sin.

But how does the truth set us free from sin?

Martin Luther defined sin as the state of being curved in on the self.  Sin is when I put my preferences, my desires, my ideas, my plans, my goals above and before everyone and everything else.  Sin is me, me, me, me, me taken to the extent that it harms or disenfranchises or marginalizes or disempowers or diminishes or neglects you, you, you, you, you.  Sin creates a false reality, an illusion centered on my desires, my fears, my imagination—the way I want things to be.  And that illusion is seductive and captivating.  It ensnares.  It enslaves.  It makes me believe that I am the center of the universe, that what I think or believe or even just what I want very, very badly to be true is what is real.

Truth disabuses me of that illusion.

Once again: Truth means that my desires or imagination do not have the final word in determining what is reality and what is not.

We are currently struggling through a time when truth is endangered in our culture.  There’s nothing new about that.  People have always preferred to put their own spin on facts that confront their biases or preconceived ideas.  People throughout history have taken refuge in denial when events or outcomes don’t fit the way they wanted things to happen or give them the results they wanted.  What’s new is how widespread this devaluation of the truth has become.

When lies and spin become so prevalent that they begin to undermine any common understanding of basic facts, the world becomes a more dangerous place.  When people refuse to accept observable facts, when there is no longer the common cultural ground of truth based on fact, then there is no longer a starting point for discussion or compromise.  There is no way to move past confrontation and opposed binary positions that divide us.  When people lift up conspiracy theories and “alternative facts” as justification for their actions or opinions then we stand on the precipice of political violence.

Sadly, we have seen too many clear examples of that in the last few years.  It has become the sin of our society.

Sin convinces me that I stand apart from the rest of humanity.  But the truth, the fact, is that I am deeply and intimately connected to the rest of humanity and, in fact, to all of creation.  Standing apart is an illusion.  Rugged individualism is a destructive myth—destructive because it undermines and negates the relationships that keep us alive in every sense of the word.

“We must all overcome the illusion of separateness,” said Richard Rohr.  “It is the primary task of religion to communicate not worthiness but union, to reconnect people to their original identity ‘hidden with Christ in God’ (Colossians 3:3). The Bible calls the state of separateness ‘sin.’ God’s job description is to draw us back into primal and intimate relationship. As 1 John 3:2 reminds us, ‘My dear people, we are already children of God; what we will be in the future has not yet been fully revealed, and all I do know is that we shall be like God.’”

As followers of Jesus, we are called to live in the imitation of Christ.  We are called to observe what God is doing all the time and everywhere and then do the same.  We are called to be generous because God is generous.  We are called to be creative because God is creative.  We are called to embrace diversity because God revels in diversity so much that no two things are exactly alike in the entire universe.  But above and beyond everything else, we are called to love.  Because God loves.  God is love.  And, as Richard Rohr has said, God does not love us if and when we change.  God loves us so that we can change.

That is grace—the grace that makes us whole, the grace that heals us, the grace that reunites us, the grace that saves us.

Claim it.  Revel in it.  Believe it.  Embrace it.

It’s the truth…and it’s the only thing that can set us free.

Show Me The Coin

Matthew 22:15-22

A lot of people had the day off this past Monday for Columbus Day, which is still a Federal Holiday although a growing number of businesses and institutions no longer observe it.  Some people are now observing Indigenous Peoples Day instead, in honor of the original inhabitants of the North and South American continents who were displaced by European immigrants.

Which day do you observe?

Last Monday was also the anniversary of the first time the Pledge of Allegiance was recited in the public schools.  On October 12, 1892, several thousand students in the New York Public Schools system started their school day by reciting the Pledge of Allegiance which had been published a month earlier in The Youth’s Companion magazine.

The pledge was written by Francis Bellamy, a Baptist minister and Christian Socialist, who was removed from his pulpit in Boston for proclaiming that Jesus was a Socialist and for preaching against capitalism which he said is essentially evil because it is based on greed.  Interestingly, he later went to work in advertising.  Bellamy believed in the absolute separation of church and state and he intentionally did not include the phrase “under God” in his pledge.  Those words were inserted at the urging of President Eisenhower in 1954 during the Cold War.

Not everyone likes the Pledge of Allegiance.  The Amish, the Mennonites and Jehovah’s Witnesses have always refused to recite the pledge, insisting that all our allegiance properly belongs to God, so in 1943 the Supreme Court ruled that students could not be forced to participate in the pledge.[1] Not everyone abstains from the pledge on religious grounds.  Some have refrained from reciting the pledge for reasons of civility and inclusivity.  Both the Rotary Club and Kiwanis Club of Palo Alto and the Palo Alto Chamber of Commerce voted in 2019 to forgo reciting the pledge  so as not to offend noncitizens or others in attendance who might object.

How do you feel about the pledge?  Do you recite it or do you abstain?

What about having a flag in church?  Are you in favor or opposed?

Which side are you on?

Do you lean right, or do you lean left?

Do you favor autocracy or democracy?

Are you a Republican or a Democrat or a Democratic Socialist or a Libertarian?

Are you aligned with the Progressives or the Conservatives?

Are you Pro-Life or Pro-Choice?

Do you support the separation of Church and State or are you a Christian Nationalist?

I don’t know about you, but questions like these make me itch.  These are loaded questions.  Binary questions.  Sorting questions.  Questions like this have an agenda and they are as old and merciless as politics.

In today’s gospel lesson, we get a terrific example of a political sorting question calculated to get Jesus in trouble one way or another. The really fascinating thing about it is that the Pharisees and the Herodians, two political factions who usually wanted nothing to do with each other, came together to ask this question.  That’s how much they wanted to discredit Jesus. That’s how much they wanted him out of the way.

After buttering him up with a compliment about his impeccable impartiality they drop their bomb, their loaded question:  “Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar or not?”

The particular tax they were asking about was the Tribitum Capitis, a tax of one denarius per year levied on every adult man and woman in the empire who was not a Roman citizen.  This tax was first administered in Israel in 6 CE when Judea was officially annexed as a Roman province.  Its specific purpose was to pay for the occupation and administration of Rome’s conquered territories.

The Herodians were big supporters of Herod Antipas and Herod Antipas was a big supporter of Rome, so the Herodians were all in favor of the tax as a way to help pay for what they saw as the many benefits of being part of the empire—good roads, improved trade, aqueducts, strictly enforced law and order, and so on.

The Pharisees, on the other hand, were not enthusiastic fans of their Roman overlords and were not at all happy about the tax that paid for the soldiers who filled their streets so that a foreign power could dominate every aspect of their lives in their own homeland.  They also had a very serious problem with Roman money.

Roman currency was not just money, it was also political propaganda.  Every coin served as a reminder that Rome had complete control of the economy.  On one side of the Roman denarius was a portrait of the emperor to remind everyone that just about every aspect of public life was governed by the emperor and his tyrannical hierarchy of officials.  The other side of the coin depicted Pax, the goddess of peace, to remind the people that Rome kept the peace… with swords and spears.

To devout Jews like the Pharisees, the images stamped on these coins were a kind of idolatry.  But worse than the images was the inscription on the coins: Tiberius Caesar, Son of the Divine Augustus, Pontifex Maximus.  The coin proclaimed not only that the emperor was the son of a god, but also the high priest of the empire’s religions. All of the empire’s religions.  Including theirs.

When the Pharisees and the Herodians team up to ask Jesus their loaded question, they think they have him trapped.  If he says, “No, it’s not right to pay this tax,” he will make the Pharisees and a lot of others in the crowd happy, but he will be guilty of sedition against Rome, and the Herodians won’t waste a minute bringing it to Pilate’s attention.  If he says, “Yes, it’s perfectly fine to pay the tax,” then he will disappoint the crowd and give the Pharisees ammunition to discredit him.

But instead of falling into their binary yes-or-no trap, Jesus exposes it.  He makes it clear that he is aware of their bad intentions and he makes the crowd aware that there is no sincerity or honesty in their tricky question.  He reveals their malice and antagonism with a very straightforward question of his own:  “Why are you trying to trap me, you hypocrites?”

Jesus probably could say a lot more about their hypocrisy and attempted entrapment, but like all good rabbis, he knows a teaching moment when he sees one.  “Show me the coin used for the tax,” he says.  It seems clear that he doesn’t have one.  That’s an important detail that should not be overlooked.

Jesus does not have the coin.  But someone does.  Someone, probably one of the Herodians, hands him the silver denarius, and Jesus, holding it up for all to see, asks, “Whose head is this, and whose title?”  “Caesar’s,” they reply.

I imagine this was a tense moment.  I can imagine him holding that coin in his hand, evaluating the stamped metal portrait in his palm for a long moment before he hands the coin back to whomever gave it to him and says, “Then give back to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”

When they heard this, the text says, they were astonished, so  they left him and went away.

What exactly was Jesus saying?  What does it mean to give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s?

On the face of it, it sounds easy.  On the face of it, it sounds like another simple binary division, like we can divide life into two compartments: on one side of the line are the things that belong to God, spiritual things, and on the other side of the line are secular things.  Like politics.  Or economics.

If only life were that simple.  But it’s not.  Life is complex and complicated.  Sometimes we struggle to find a path that doesn’t compromise either our faith or our alliances and allegiances or our obligations.

What really belongs to Caesar?  Does his own likeness?   Genesis tells us that we were created in the image and likeness of God, so in that sense, isn’t Caesar’s own likeness something that, in the end, belongs to God?

Does the silver in the coin that bears his picture belong to Caesar?  He may be in possession of it or exercise some control over its distribution and its value in the marketplace, but isn’t God the one who brought into being both the silver and the man whose image is stamped on it?  Long after Caesar has been gathered to his ancestors, the silver will pass to other hands and be melted down for other uses and only God will know where it is.  Psalm 24 tells us, “The earth is the Lord’s and all that is in it, the world, and those who live in it.”  So when all is said and done, doesn’t everything belong to God in whom we live and move and have our being?

When Jesus says, “Give back to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s,” he is asking them to locate themselves in the tension between Caesar’s dominion and the reign of God.  And he is asking the same thing of us.

The coin that was used to pay the tax in question was a perfect symbol of empire’s dominance.  With the emperor’s likeness it proclaimed his singular sovereignty.  With its depiction of the goddess Pax, it proclaimed the empire’s definition of peace, a peace obtained and maintained by violence and force.  With its inscription that asserted the divinity of the emperor and affirmed him as Pontifex Maximus, it declared the empire’s control of religion and made a claim on everyone’s faith. And the fact that this silver denarius was the standard day’s wage throughout the empire made it the symbol of the empire’s vast economic power.  It was, in and of itself, a statement.  It said, “If you’re going to participate in the economy, you are participating in empire.  If you buy or sell anything, you are participating in empire.  When you go to the market to buy olives and flour and oil and fruit and lentils, the basic necessities of life, you are going to have to compromise your religious principles because you are going to use the empire’s coin to do it.”

And this is where it is important to remember that Jesus did not have the coin.

Jesus did not have the coin.

What side are you on?  In a world that confronts us with so many binary choices, how do we decide where to stand?  Is there a way for us to speak truth like Rabbi Jesus without carrying the coin of someone else’s agenda or dominance?

“Give back to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.”

It seems so simple, but it’s not.  It is, in fact, immensely complicated.  Like life.

When Jesus tells us to give to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s and to God the things that are God’s he isn’t sidestepping the tricky tax question.  Instead, he is asking us to do some serious thinking.  Philosophical thinking.  Theological thinking.  And practical thinking.  He acknowledges that we live with difficult questions and he asks us to not simply settle for clichéd or easy answers.  He asks us to think about what’s best not just for ourselves but also for our neighbors who live with us in the interconnected religious, social, economic and political webs that both enrich and complicate our lives.

What belongs to Caesar and what belongs to God?   Jesus won’t answer that question for us in advance because there is no easy answer.  There is only your answer.  And my answer.  And the way we answer that question shows us the shape of our faith.  You might even say it’s the currency—the coin–of our faith… in Jesus’ name.


[1] West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette

Good Trouble

Matthew 21:23-32

“When you see something that is not right, not fair, not just, you have to speak up,” said the late John Lewis. “You have to say something.  You have to do something.  You must be bold, brave and courageous and find a way to get in the way, to get in trouble.  Good trouble.  Necessary trouble.”[1]

From the moment Jesus entered Jerusalem, he was getting in the way and making trouble.  Good trouble.  He came into the city with a bit of satirical street theater straight out of the prophetic writings of Zechariah.  His Palm Sunday parade into the city was a parody of Roman pageantry and a protest against the arrogant and oppressive might of Rome as it was being displayed by Pontius Pilate who, at that same moment, was entering Jerusalem on the other side of the city with a military procession of cavalry and soldiers.  Instead of a white charger, Jesus was riding a donkey.  Instead of the mandated shouts of “hail Caesar,” the crowd spreading branches and cloaks in front of Jesus cried out “Hosannah.  Save us, Son of David.”  

Soon after entering the city, Jesus went to the temple and drove out the money changers and all the merchants who were buying and selling sacrificial animals.  He may have found all the noise and smell and mess and open commerce at the temple disturbing,  but he was absolutely outraged at the brazen thievery of the money changers who fleeced the poor with extortionate exchange rates.  On top of that, he was furious because they had set up their market in the Court of the Gentiles, the only place at the temple where Gentiles were allowed to gather and pray to Israel’s God.  In his anger he quoted both Isaiah and Jeremiah when he said, “My house shall be called a house of prayer, but you have made it a den of robbers,”[2]  and the language he used makes it clear that he regarded what they are doing as a kind of violence. 

Matthew tells us that after things calmed down “the blind and the lame came to him in the temple and he cured them.”  Matthew also notes that little children were repeating the hosannahs they had heard their parents singing out in the streets.  So you have to believe that all of this was working the nerves of the chief priests and the scribes.   

And then there was that business with the fig tree.

Let’s talk about that fig tree.

The fig tree carried a lot of freight as a symbol in ancient Jewish culture and religion.  It symbolized peace, prosperity, wisdom and the study of Torah.  Rabbis would gather their students under the shade of a fig tree to study the scriptures and to meditate on their meaning.  The phrase “every man under his vine and his fig tree” from 1 Kings envisioned a promised Messianic golden age of peace, safety and abundance for Israel.  A profusion of fig trees in the land indicated that the nation was at peace and experiencing God’s favor.  The prophets used the fig tree as a metaphor for the nation of Israel as a whole:  In prophetic imagery a thriving tree represented physical and spiritual health while a fruitless tree was a sign of spiritual sickness and a warning of impending judgment.

So, on the morning after Jesus had driven the moneychangers out of the temple, Matthew tells us “when he returned to the city, he was hungry, and seeing a fig tree by the side of the road, he went to it but found nothing at all on it but leaves. Then he said to the tree, ‘May no fruit ever come from you again!’ and the fig tree withered at once.”[3]  

When Jesus cursed the fig tree he was symbolically delivering a prophetic indictment against Israel’s spiritual leadership by the temple authorities.  It would have been seen as an omen of coming disaster for the nation.  So it’s no surprise that the chief priests and elders interrupt Jesus while he’s teaching in the temple and ask him, “By what authority are you doing these things, and who gave you this authority?”

It’s a legitimate question and they have every right to ask it.  It’s their responsibility to ensure that everything that happens in the temple is done in conformity with the traditions of their people and the teachings of Torah.  It’s also their job to keep a lid on any kind of activity that might aggravate their  Roman overlords.  Jesus is pushing all their buttons, so they ask him:  “By what authority are you doing these things, and who gave you that authority?”

It’s a legitimate question, but it’s also a “gotcha” question.  It was a question designed to put Jesus on the spot.  There aren’t too many answers he could give that wouldn’t open the door to more trouble.  But Jesus knows it’s not quite time yet for his final confrontation at the corner of religion and politics and he is too smart to fall into their trap.  

“Let me ask you a question,” said Jesus.  “If you answer my question then I’ll answer yours.  So tell me, who authorized the baptism of John—was it from heaven or was it merely human?”  

This question that Jesus asked was also a “gotcha” question and now the temple authorities were on the spot.  Matthew tells us they started arguing with each other.  “If we say, ‘John’s baptism came from heaven,’ he’ll ask us, ‘Then why didn’t you believe him?’  But if we say, ‘John’s baptism was merely a human thing,’ the crowd will turn against us because they all think John was a prophet.”  In the end, they gave up and simply answered, “We don’t know.”  

“Fine,” said Jesus.  “Then I’m not going to answer your question.”

What the temple authorities didn’t realize was that Jesus could have asked them a much harder question that would have made things much more awkward for them than they already were.  He could have turned their own question back on them:  By what authority do you do the things you do in the temple and who gave you that authority?

That would have been a very uncomfortable question for the chief priests and elders.    

It had been a very long time since the priests in the temple had been appointed by any religious or hereditary authority.  When Herod the Great became king he felt that the temple priests had too much power so he removed them from office then replaced the high priest with an obscure priest from Babylon who would be easier to manipulate.  Later, the Romans assumed the power of appointing the temple priests, and they, too, made a point of choosing men they knew they could control.  If Jesus had asked the priests and elders the question they had asked him, “By what authority do you do these things?” they would have had to publicly admit that they were appointed by the Roman authorities and that their service in the temple all too often required them to cooperate with the empire’s demands and dictates.  

Jesus could have made the moment much more awkward for the priests who were questioning him but Jesus was always, first and foremost, a teacher, so instead of blatantly exposing and denouncing their complicity with the empire, he created a teaching moment.  He told them a parable.

“Here’s a little story,” he said.  “Tell me what you think.”  A man had two sons.  He went to his first son and said, ‘Son, go out and work in the vineyard today.” “No,” said his son, “I really don’t want to.”  But later he changed his mind and went out to do what his father asked.  The father went to the second son and said, “Son, go out and work in the vineyard today.”  “I will go out right now,” said the son.  But he never left the house.  “Now,” said Jesus, “which of the two sons did what the father asked?” 

Jesus wanted the priests and elders to see themselves in this little parable.  He wanted them to understand that they were like the son who said yes to the father’s request but did not actually obey by doing the work.  To bring home the point, he lifted up the social outcasts who had responded to John the Baptist in ways that had transformed their lives.

“I’ll tell you what,” said Jesus. “The tax collectors and sex workers are going into the kingdom of God ahead of you.  John came to you in the way of righteousness and you did not believe him.  But the tax collectors and sex workers believed him.  Yet even after you saw how these people were changed for the better you still didn’t change your minds and trust John.”

“When you see something that is not right, not fair, not just, you have to speak up. You have to say something.  You have to do something,” said John Lewis.  “You must…find a way to get in the way, to get in trouble.  Good trouble.  Necessary trouble.”[4]

That is exactly what Jesus did.  He saw religious authorities collaborating with a brutally oppressive empire.  He saw those same authorities failing to intervene as swindlers grifted people out of their hard-earned money in the very courts of the temple.  He saw devout and curious Gentiles seeking a quiet moment with Israel’s God in a holy place squeezed out of the place that had been explicitly created for them, the only place in the temple where they were allowed to pray.  So he found a way to get in the way.  He found a way to get into trouble.  Good trouble.  And he did it all without violence.

He got in the way with parody and parables.  He symbolically pronounced judgment on the pious guardians of religious hierarchy and authority by cursing the symbolic emblem spiritual health.  He disrupted the economic machinery of the temple without abusing the people operating that machinery.  When they tried to entrap him with “gotcha” questions he responded with difficult questions of his own but refrained from asking the question that had the power to destroy them.

At the corner of Religion and Politics, Jesus saw something that was not right, not just, not fair.  So he got in the way.  He got into trouble.  Necessary trouble.  Good trouble. 

And he asks us to do the same.


[1] Rep. John Lewis, 2014 Commencement Speech at Emory University

[2] Isaiah 56:7; Jeremiah 7:11

[3] Matthew 21:18-19

[4] Rep. John Lewis, 2014 Commencement Speech at Emory University

Cross Purposes

Matthew 16:13-28

Now when Jesus came into the district of Caesarea Philippi, he asked his disciples, “Who do people say that the Son of Man is?” And they said, “Some say John the Baptist but others Elijah and still others Jeremiah or one of the prophets.” He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Simon Peter answered, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.”… Then he sternly ordered the disciples not to tell anyone that he was the Messiah.  From that time on, Jesus began to show his disciples that he must go to Jerusalem and undergo great suffering at the hands of the elders and chief priests and scribes and be killed and on the third day be raised.  –Matthew 16:13-20

This is the turning point in the Synoptic gospels.  In Mark it comes in chapter 8, almost exactly in the middle.  In Matthew and Luke it doesn’t fall at the midpoint of the literary structure but it is, nonetheless, the turning point in their telling of the Christ story because this is when Jesus turns toward Jerusalem and the cross.  It is also a turning point in the disciples’ understanding of who Jesus is and what he is about, a moment in which they begin to see him in a new way, a moment when they begin to wrestle with their commitment to him and their own decision to follow him.  It is the beginning of their transformation.  And it all begins with the question: “Who do you say that I am?”

You are the Messiah,” said Peter.  

And he sternly ordered them not to tell anyone.  Why?  Because he knows that even after all this time with him they don’t really have a clue what God’s Messiah is all about.  He knows that their whole religion, their whole culture, has a very, very mistaken idea of who the Messiah is and what the Messiah will do.  He knows that they’re expecting Power and Domination and Armies of Angels.

But this is a turning point.  So he tells them what’s going to happen in Jerusalem.  He spells out for them the reality of what it means to be the Messiah under the heavy political hand of the Empire.  He reminds them that empires do not have much patience for messiahs.  He tells them that it’s going to be very, very bad and brutal.  He tells them that the empire going to win, but in reality they won’t win anything because what the empire thinks is the end of the story will be, in reality, a new beginning.  But it’s not going to happen with Power and Domination and Armies of Angels.  It will be Power and Domination and the Army of Empire who nail him to the cross, because that’s what Power and Domination and Armies do. On that cross Jesus, Emmanuel, God with Us, will not display Omniscience and Omnipresence and Omnipotence—on that cross God in Christ will eschew every power except love.  Because Power is always coercive and corrosive.  And peace and transformation that comes through coercion is no peace at all.

Jesus tells them that it’s going to be ugly.  So Peter rebukes him.  At least Peter had the honest frankness to tell Jesus to his face that he didn’t like what he was hearing.  How often do we  do that?  How often are we so straightforward with Jesus?  How often are we simply passively resistant to Jesus or even passively aggressive in trying to reshape him to fit our belligerent agendas?  How often do we just discard Jesus altogether and put up a kind of pantomime Jesus behind a wall of carefully cherry-picked Scriptures which rarely, if ever, actually include things Jesus himself said because we want to summon the powerful political forces of our religion’s tradition and use them as a Billy club against a changing world that makes us squirm with discomfort?  And how many times, when we do that, are we actually putting ourselves in opposition to what Jesus is doing?  How many times do we end up opposing the Holy Spirit’s own work of transformation with our false Christ because the real Jesus just won’t be who we want him to be or say what we want him to say?

How else do you explain Christian Nationalism?  How else do you explain advertisements for a “Christian” Assault Rifle, an AR-15 with a Knights Templar cross on one side of the magazine and Psalm 144:1 on the other: Blessed be the LORD, my rock, who trains my hands for war, and my fingers for battle.

Get behind me, Satan.  You’re setting your mind on human things instead of divine things.  

What does the cross mean to you?

If you put aside all the official church answers—all the Sunday School responses, atonement theories, confirmation lessons—what does the cross mean to you?

What does it mean to you when Jesus says that if you want to be his disciple you have to shoulder your own cross—carry your own cross?

Jesus was carrying his cross during his entire ministry.

From the time he first stood up in the synagogue and read from Isaiah—“The Spirit of the Lord is upon me…see, the Lord has anointed me to bring good news to the poor, recovery of sight to the blind, to liberate the oppressed and set the captives free and to announce that now is the time of God’s favor” he was making himself a target.

From the moment he began to announce that the Kingdom of God—the commonwealth of God’s justice and mercy—was at hand, was arriving, was within reach he was setting himself in opposition to empire and standing starkly silhouetted in the empire’s crosshairs.

From the moment he began to teach he was carrying the burden of trying to teach people to understand the world in a new way, to see it in a new way, to see each other in a new way he was conspicuously wading against the stream of the status quo.  

He was carrying his cross.

When he preached the beatitudes to show them—to show us—how we’re supposed to treat each other and how things are supposed to work in this God-made, God-beloved world

—when he spent time with all those outsiders that “nice” people didn’t associate with, all the “sinners” and tax collectors and prostitutes and Samaritans

—when he healed on the Sabbath and challenged the Pharisees and Scribes and taunted Herod

—when he asked them to open their eyes to see what their privilege was costing their poorer brothers and sisters

—when he said things that challenged tradition and infuriated people so much they wanted to throw him off a cliff

—he was deliberately risking the fire of their animosity by confronting all the hypocrisy of their religious and political systems, all the little compromises they made with themselves and with the structures of society to make things run smoothly and preserve their comfortable lives.  He was calling into question all the things that made them feel right, and safe and secure, and sure of their place in the grand scheme of things.  

Long before he stood before Pilate, long before they laid the wood across his shoulders, he was carrying his cross.  

And he didn’t do all this just to be the sacrificial offering in some mythic deal with God so he could magic away our sins.  He did it for exactly the reasons he announced when he read from Isaiah: To announce good news to the poor.  To open the eyes of people blinded by their habits and assumptions.  To release people from all kinds of things that oppressed them or held them captive—even things like their own greed or self-interest or ruthless ambition.

He carried the burden, the cross, of risking people’s anger and violence, knowing full well that it would end in a real cross, in order to show them a better way of being in the world.  

And the crowds followed him because his words were filled with promise and joy and love and gave them hope for a better life.  And love and compassion that flowed from him like living water had the power to heal.  

But he wanted them to understand that to do the work he was doing what was needed was not crowds but disciples.  Followers who would really take what he was saying to heart and live it day in and day out just as he was living it.  

He wanted them to know that following in the crowd and being a disciple are two different things.   

And he wanted them to know it wasn’t easy to be a disciple.  That it came at a cost.  That there was a cross to carry.  That they would be misunderstood.  That even people who claimed to be reading the same sacred texts and worshipping the same God would bristle when the liberating Word of God pushed on certain sensitive topics or challenged their thinking.

He wanted them to know that being a disciple isn’t safe.

There’s no shame in being in the crowd.  The crowd has its role and its place.  Jesus has compassion on the crowd.  He feeds the crowd.  He cares for the crowd.  But it’s the disciples who he calls to help him do the work of making God’s reign a reality on earth as it is in heaven.  The crowd are consumers.  Disciples are providers.

So he wanted them to know they had a choice.  

You have a choice.  You can be in the crowd.  Or you can be a disciple.  And I hope you do choose to be a disciple because the only thing that’s going to change the world, the only thing that’s going to heal the world is if enough of us stand up to confront the world with love. 

If you want to be a disciple…if you think Christ is calling you to be a disciple think long and hard.  Jesus spent 40 days and nights in the desert thinking about it before he picked up his cross.

And that leads us back to where we started.   If you are a disciple, where is love leading you?  If you shoulder a cross, whose burden will you carry?  Whose load are you lifting?  Who are you freeing—and from what?  Who will you protect?  Where will you take a stand?  Where will you put your life on the line for the life of others?

What does the cross mean to you?

The Keys of Heaven

The body of the old man lay stretched out upon the table, prepared according to custom and covered with a shroud.  The presbyter, who had been gazing out the window, or perhaps deep into his own thoughts, broke from his reverie, stood up, removed a papyrus scroll from the folds of his robe, then moved to the body lying on the table.  Gently, reverently, he lifted the edge of the shroud and took something from the right hand of the old man lying beneath it, then lifted it high in the lamplight for all to see.  

The others in the room reacted as he lifted the familiar object high so that it dangled before them.  Some smiled wistfully.  A few nodded in recognition.  One woman buried her face in her scarf and wept.  

It was a plain thing, a simple leather thong suspending ten stones, seven smaller, three larger, each separated from the others by a knot in the leather.  They did not catch the light in any particular way.  They did not glow or sparkle.  There was no mystic aura about them.  But the faithful people in that gathering would not have traded those stones for rubies or diamonds or sapphires or pearls. 

“The Keys to Heaven,” said the presbyter, then with care bordering on ceremony he handed the odd artifact to the deaconess who stood at the feet of the old man’s corpse.  She cradled the leather strip and its stones in her open hands, holding it out so all could see it in the soft glow of the oil lamps.  After a moment, the presbyter unrolled the scroll and began to read.

By vocation, the presbyter was the chief reader at a busy scriptorium.  Six days of the week he would read aloud to a phalanx of copyists—reading slowly, distinctly, and loudly enough to be heard at the back of the room yet fast enough to keep up with the demands of the business, to meet its deadlines and keep it profitable.  The qualities that made him so very good at his job also made him an excellent public Lector, a role which added to his income.  This talent served him well, of course, in his role as presbyter, the chief elder in this small community of the faithful.  But now, as he began to read his dear friend’s last will and testament, he put aside his professional voice and tried to find in himself the deep wells of strength and gentleness that characterized his departed friend, doing his best to summon his friend’s voice for his friend’s words.  This is what he read:

“My dear friends, my brothers and sisters, grace to you and peace in the name of the One we follow, who was, who is and who is to come.  Amen.  I pray you know how much you are loved.   I have so very little to leave to you in the way of earthly things.  My little house and my poor purse I entrust to this community.  Perhaps they may be used to benefit a widow or two.  Let the Deaconess administer these things as she is most capable.  Let the tools of my trade go Nathaniel, my apprentice.  I have no other possessions except the Keys to Heaven.  These I bequeath to you all for your common use and good, but I must tell you how I came to have them.

“I think that almost every one of you, most when you were children, but some when you were older, have asked me, ‘Andreas, what are those stones hanging from your belt?’ and I would say, ‘They are the Keys to Heaven and I am giving them to you.’  Then you would say, ‘When can I have them?’  And I would say, ‘When you can tell me how they are made!’ So now, I will tell you their story.

“For all the years I have lived among you, you have known me as Andreas the Leatherworker.  That was not always my name.  For that matter, working leather was not always my trade, but that is of no importance.  When I was much younger and full of anger at the world I did some dangerous and stupid things.  One thing in particular was even evil, though I did not think so at the time.  As a consequence, I found myself on the run, hiding from the patrols of soldiers that seemed to be everywhere on the road.  I cut my hair and shaved my beard.  I stole the tunic, mantle and belt of a tradesman while he was bathing in the river and left my very fine and costly clothes in their place.  Then I fastened a sword to my belt and kept on running.

“Three nights later, just at nightfall, I saw a man sitting by a campfire just to the side of the road.  Half mad with hunger and exhaustion, I moved toward him, drew my sword and said, ‘Give me your food and your money.’  I meant to growl it out in a menacing way but my throat was so parched I must have croaked like a raven.  

   ‘We will gladly share our food with you,’ said the man, ‘but what money we have with us is not ours to give.’  I started to move toward him with my sword when his words pierced the fog of my hunger.  We.  He had said ‘we.’  I blinked, looked again, and could not believe I had not seen them the first time—four other men. Two of them were some small distance behind the man by the fire but were now walking briskly toward us.  Another man was emerging from the brush carrying an armload of wood for the fire, and another with a water skin was just coming up from the stream.  Five men altogether.  Even if I were not nearly dead from hunger and thirst I could never take on five men.  My head began to swim, my knees gave out and I fell, unconscious.

   “I awakened to find one of the men bathing my forehead with a cool, wet cloth while another was bandaging my arm.  Apparently I had cut it with my own sword when I fell.  The man I had first seen, the one I had threatened and tried to rob, lifted a cup of cool water to my lips but urged me to drink it slowly.  As soon as I was able to sit up one of the men gave me a piece of bread and a piece of dried fish which I devoured immediately without a word.

   “I didn’t know what to expect next and I was too weak to try to run.  When the big man, the first man I had seen by the fire, picked up my sword I half expected him to kill me with it. Instead he laid it in front of me in the dirt.  ‘This is yours,’ he said, “though I think you might be better off not to keep it. That’s a Roman Gladius. A soldier’s sword.  And you don’t strike me as a soldier. I think maybe that sword has already brought you trouble and if I were you I would just bury it here at the side of the road.’  I was dumbstruck.  That sword had been nothing but trouble.  That sword and my hot temper were the whole reason I had had to flee for my life.

   “I looked at the big man.  He was smiling at me, and I realized, looking at him, that there was no fear in him.  No anger.  “You must still be hungry,” he said.  

   ‘I tried to rob you!’ I said, incredulous.  ‘I threatened you!’  

   ‘Yes.  You did,’ he said.  ‘I forgive you.’  

   ‘But I…’  I started.  

   ‘Let it go,’ he said, quietly.  ‘I have.  What you bind on earth is bound in heaven.  What you release on earth is released in heaven.  I release it.  I release you.  Let it go.’

“I sat staring at the ground for a long time, confused, not knowing what to think.  After a moment, I heard him chuckle, looked up and saw him smiling at me.  He leaned over and picked up a smooth agate pebble from the ground, walked over and placed it in my hand.  ‘Here,’ he said. ‘Keep this.  This is the first Key to Heaven.  Forgiveness.’ 

   ‘I don’t know if I can be forgiven.’ I said.  His expression became reflective and he gazed into the fire for a long moment. 

   ‘I felt that way once,’ he said at last. ‘I betrayed my best friend…my teacher…my master.  I betrayed him three times in one night to save my own skin.’ 

   ‘What happened?” I asked.  

   ‘They crucified him,’ he said simply.  ‘But I got away because I pretended that I didn’t know him. Three times in one night someone accused me of being one of his companions and three times I denied it.  And I didn’t think I would ever be forgiven for that.  But he forgave me.  And he helped me forgive myself.  He released me from my sin and he helped me let go of my sin—helped me to stop clinging to it..’  

   ‘Wait a minute,” I said, ‘I though you said they crucified him.’  

   ‘They did,’ he said.  

   ‘Well then how…when did he forgive you?’ 

“The way he looked at me I could tell he was trying to decide something and it was another very long moment before he said, ‘That’s another story and if you would like to travel with us I will gladly tell it another day.  For now,’ and here he smiled again, ‘hold on to that little piece of forgiveness and let that be enough for today.’

“And that, my beloved brothers and sisters is how I came to have the first of the Keys of Heaven, the Key of Forgiveness.  Having nowhere else to go and nothing to lose, I became a travelling companion of Petrus, the Fisherman, who taught me the ways of his Master and baptized me into a new life with a new name.  And along the way he gave me the Keys of Heaven and taught me how they are made, or where they can be discovered, so that each of us can have them and carry them with us and unlock Heaven around us wherever we are.  

“The first key is Forgiveness.  The Second is Gratitude.  The third is Generosity.  The fourth is Compassion. These four open your heart to the world God made, the world God loves.  The fifth key is Integrity.  The Sixth is Thoughtfulness.  These two open the soul and mind to look beyond yourself and deal fairly with all others.  The seventh is Be Not Afraid.  This key gives you the presence of mind to remember that you have all the others at your command and it helps you to use them wisely.

Then there are the three larger keys.  These give the first keys their power.  At the same time, the first keys can unlock the power of these three.  They are Faith, Hope and Love.

“So, my beloved friends, these are the Keys to Heaven.  I hope you can see that I spoke the truth all these years when I said, ‘I am giving them to you.’  I hope and pray that in my life you saw forgiveness, gratitude, generosity, compassion, integrity and thoughtfulness.  I hope you saw me live without fear.  I pray that you are gathering these keys for yourself by the example of our Master.  May you all continue to grow in Faith, Hope and Love until we are reunited in the Life to Come.

Peace be with you.

I am always your brother,

Andreas”

The small assembly sang a hymn.  The presbyter pronounced a benediction.  The deaconess replaced the Keys of Heaven in the old man’s hand, and in the dim lamplight they reverently carried his body to its place of rest.  

Thought Pollution

Matthew 15:21-28 and Mark 7:24-30

Are there stories or sayings in the Bible that make you uncomfortable?  This story of Jesus and the Canaanite woman has really bothered me for a long time, mostly because at first reading Jesus come off as a bit of a jerk.  But here’s the thing:  I think this story is supposed to be disturbing.  It’s supposed to bother us.  

This story is begging us to do our homework, because we won’t even begin to understand what Jesus is up to here unless we dig into some history and social context.  I’m pretty sure that Jesus was aiming for a particular reaction from his disciples and I think he wants that same reaction from us.  But for us to get to the “aha moment” here, we really need to go back.  Way back.  All the way back to Noah.

But before we set the Wayback Machine for Noah, let’s go back to what happened just before Jesus encountered this bothersome and determined Canaanite woman. 

At the end of the previous chapter, after a stormy night on the lake where Jesus walked on water and Peter tried to, they landed at the little town of Gennesaret.  As always, a crowd gathered and Jesus started teaching.  But before he got very far some Pharisees and scribes started to give him a bad time because his disciples didn’t wash their hands before eating.  So Jesus tells the crowd to gather round then says, “Listen and understand:  it is not what goes into the mouth that defiles a person.  It’s what comes out of the mouth that defiles.”  This offended the Pharisees.  And it probably offended them even more when Jesus called them blind guides of the blind.  

But Peter wanted to hear more about what goes into the mouth versus what comes out.  I really like how Eugene Peterson rendered this bit of dialogue in The Message Bible:

“Peter said, ‘I don’t get it. Put it in plain language.’

“Jesus replied, “You too? Are you being willfully stupid?  Don’t you know that anything that is swallowed works its way through the intestines and is finally defecated?  But what comes out of the mouth gets its start in the heart. It’s from the heart that we vomit up evil arguments, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, lies, and cussing.  That’s what pollutes. Eating or not eating certain foods, washing or not washing your hands—that’s neither here nor there.’”

So keep all that in mind—those things that come out of the heart by way of the mouth to pollute life—keep all that in the back of your mind because suddenly the story shifts and in one brief sentence Jesus walks about fifty miles to the region of Tyre and Sidon.

Why?  Why Tyre and Sidon?  Did he just want to put some distance between himself and the Pharisees and scribes?  Why does he suddenly head off for Gentile territory?  Why, of all places, Sidon?

Well to answer that, we go all the way back to Noah.  

After Noah left the ark he planted a vineyard.  He grew some grapes and made some wine.  And then he got drunk and fell asleep naked in his tent.  Like you do.  Noah’s son, Ham, wandered by, noticed that his father was naked, and covered him up which actually seems like a pretty decent thing to do.  But when Noah woke up things got weird. He was furious that Ham had seen him in such a state, so he cursed Ham with a curse that would apply to all of his descendants.  

They took cursing very seriously in those days, especially being cursed by your father.  Being cursed was devastating.  It was the opposite pole of blessing.  A blessing could give you a bright vision of your future and a big dose of optimism to help make it come true.  A curse would make your life a living nightmare. It would haunt you and hang over you like a shadow.  

So Ham was cursed.  And so was his son, Canaan.  And so was Canaan’s son, Sidon.  And on down the line.

Sidon, Noah’s grandson, inheritor of the curse, ended up having a lot of sons and grandsons and great-grandsons and so on until Sidon became a great nation.  And because Sidon’s territory butted right up against Israel, and because  the two nations were somewhat less than friendly, the nation of Sidon shows up fairly often in the history and scriptures of Israel.  

In the Book of Judges, the Sidonians conquer and oppress the Israelites.  King Solomon married several Sidonian women who then induced him to worship their goddess, Ashtoreth.  Sixty years or so later, Israel’s King Ahab also married a Sidonian Princess named Jezebel.  You’ve probably heard of her.  She caused all kinds of trouble, especially when she kept trying to kill the prophet Elijah.  The Prophets Jeremiah, Ezekiel and Isaiah all predicted judgment and doom for Sidon because of their idolatry, but that doom kept getting delayed, maybe because the Sidonians were quick to ally themselves with whatever new empire happened to be expanding into the area.  When the Assyrians and later the Babylonians conquered Israel, they launched their ships from Tyre and their armies from Sidon.  

For devout and even slightly patriotic Jews, the region of Tyre and Sidon was not a friendly place.  In their eyes, the people there were cursed.

So why did Jesus go there?  

The obvious answer is that Jesus went there to put some distance between himself and the Pharisees and scribes.  Physical distance, cultural distance, and historical distance.  But it looks like he also went there to make a point about God’s love and grace.  Hang on, we’ll get to that.

They had no sooner arrived in this land of the accursed than a woman ran up and started screaming at them. The NRSV and other translations say she shouted, which sounds slightly nicer, but the Greek word Matthew uses is ekrazen which has a sense of both screaming and crying.  It’s a very emotional word.  

So this Canaanite woman—Mark specifies that she was Syrophoenician—comes rushing up to them and with tears and wailing pleads with Jesus to free her daughter from a demon that is  tormenting her.  “Have mercy on me, Lord, Son of David; my daughter is tormented by a demon!”  Kyrie eleison.  

And Jesus . . . ignores her.  

So she starts to plead with the disciples and pesters them to do something.  And no matter how they try to put her off, she won’t give up.  Because she’s a Mom.  A good Mom.  So finally they come to Jesus and beg him to intervene. “Send her away!” they said.  “She’s driving us crazy!”  

And this is where Jesus says the first thing that makes him sound like a jerk.  Jesus turns to this desperate woman who is frantic with fear for her demon-assaulted daughter and says, “I was sent only to the lost sheep of Israel.”

What!!???  Jesus! What the frankincense???

But she comes and kneels down in front of him and begs him.  “Lord, help me.”  

And this is where Jesus doubles down and says something truly ugly, something that makes him sound like a complete bigot.  “It’s not right to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs.”

He calls her a dog.  

And there is no way to translate this that takes away any of the sting, dreadfulness and insult.


How does this make any sense at all?  Did Jesus, the same Jesus who was criticized for hanging out with tax collectors and “sinners,” the same Jesus who crossed all kinds of boundaries to embrace all kinds of outcasts, the same Jesus who laid his hands on  lepers! did this Jesus trek all the way to the heart of Sidon just to insult this poor woman with a racial slur?

Yes.  Yes he did. Jesus schlepped all the way to Sidon to create a teaching moment that his disciples and all his followers forever after would not forget.

In this moment with this desperate woman, Jesus is saying aloud what his disciples are thinking.  He wants them to hear the ugliness of their attitudes out loud.  He has led them to the neighborhood of “those people,” the ones who they think are inferior, the ones who they think are cursed.  The ones who, in their understanding, God doesn’t much care for. 

I am not for one moment suggesting that the disciples in particular or Jews in general were xenophobic.  I’m suggesting that almost all of us are to one degree or another.  We humans have a bad tendency to “other” each other.  

Jesus wants us to hear what our othering attitudes sound like to someone on the receiving end.  He wants us to hear the ugliness of even our most benign bigotries expressed out loud in the presence of someone who is “not one of us,” not our clan, not our race, not of our culture or religion or denomination or neighborhood. Someone who doesn’t speak our language.  He wants us to hear what overt othering sounds like to someone we are prepared to dislike or disregard or even hate for no reason at all except for a long-nurtured history of othering and mistrust handed down through the generations.  He wants us to hear just how brutal inherited ill will can really be.  He wants us to understand that it has consequences.  And he wants us to understand that unlearning all that has to be intentional.  

It’s not what goes into the mouth that pollutes, it’s what comes out of the mouth…and what comes out of the mouth comes from the heart. It’s from the heart that we vomit up evil arguments, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, lies, blasphemies, bigotries, othering and racism.  That’s what pollutes us.  That’s what poisons us generation after generation.  

“It’s not right to take the children’s food and throw it to the dogs,” said Jesus.  “Yes Lord, she said, but even the dogs get to eat the scraps that fall from their master’s table.” “Woman, great is your faith!” said Jesus. “Let it be done for you as you wish.” And her daughter was healed instantly.

Such faith.  Such amazing faith to let herself be ignored then insulted and degraded all in the hope of some kind of help for her daughter, all for a scrap from the table of God’s healing love and grace.  All for a lesson that far too many of us still seem all too reluctant to learn.  

Image: Crumbs of Love (2008), Michael Cook

Who Asked You to Walk on Water?

Who Asked You to Walk on Water?

Matthew 14:22-33

After healing a multitude of people and then miraculously feeding an even bigger multitude of people, Jesus was finally going to get some time to himself.  Matthew tells us, “Immediately he made the disciples get into the boat and go on ahead to the other side, while he dismissed the crowds.  And after he had dismissed the crowds, he went up the mountain by himself to pray.”  

I think it’s safe to say that he had a lot on his mind.  He had just learned about the gruesome death of John the Baptist, the prophet who had baptized him, his predecessor in announcing the advent of the reign of God’s justice and mercy which Matthew calls “the kingdom of heaven.”  He had spent the day healing people of all kinds of illness and wounds and then miraculously feeding more than 5000 people from five loaves and two fish.  And apparently, that’s when he decided it was time to close up shop and send everybody home.

Matthew says “he made the disciples get into the boat and go on ahead to the other side.”  The Greek verb here is anagkazo.   It means “to compel.”  He compelled them to get in the boat and row away.  Then he dismissed the crowds.  Jesus was determined to have his alone time.  Go in peace, y’all.  I’ve got an appointment at the top of the hill.

I’m sure the disciples had second thoughts about rowing out onto the lake just as it was getting dark. The Sea of Galilee, also known as Lake Tiberias, also known as Lake Gennesaret, sits about 200 meters below sea level in a warm, semi-tropical basin.  Steep hills and plateaus rise sharply above the water and often cool, dry air masses rush down from the heights to collide with the warmer, moister air at the water’s surface.  Narrow ravines and wadis act as natural wind tunnels which can significantly increase the speed of descending gusts until they become fierce, water-churning  gales.   These winds can be especially intense at the north end of the lake which is where the disciples find themselves when Jesus orders them to get into the boat and go on ahead of him.

While Jesus was up on the mountain praying, the night was getting darker and the disciples were getting farther and farther from shore.  Then the wind hit them.  Matthew says “the wind was against them.”  Enantios is the Greek word.  It has a sense of intentional opposition.  The wind was opposed to them.  And it’s not just any wind.  It’s amenos, a particularly strong or fierce wind.  Matthew tells us that their boat was “battered by the waves” but basanidzo, the Greek verb means “tortured” or “tormented.”  So, yeah. The disciples are out on the lake in the dark, unable to make any progress because the wind is almost antagonistically against them and the waves are threatening to tear their boat apart.  Good times.

“And early in the morning he came walking toward them on the sea.”  That’s how the NRSV translates it which is, frankly worse than useless.  The Greek text tells us this happened during the fourth watch of the night. That’s between 3 a.m. and 6 a.m.  Still dark.  Still scary.   “When the disciples saw him walking on the sea, they were terrified, saying, “It is a ghost!’ And they cried out in fear.”   

Belief in ghosts was widespread in the ancient world, including among the Jews, so it’s not surprising that they think Jesus is a ghost.  Besides, who else could walk on water?  Must be a ghost.  These Galilean fishermen would have known more than a few friends and neighbors who had lost their lives in those waters.  On top of that, the sea, in their thinking, was a realm of chaos that harbored demons, malicious spirits, lost spirits and monsters.  So whatever or whomever it was they were seeing walking across the water, odds were not good that it would be friendly.

“But immediately Jesus spoke to them and said, ‘Take heart, it is I; do not be afraid.’”  Much has been made in some commentaries about the wording of “it is I.”  In the Greek the words are ego eimi  which is the same wording God uses in the Septuagint, the Greek translation of the Hebrew Bible, when Moses asks God for God’s name.  Ego Eimi.  I am who I am.  Some think that when Jesus says this to his frightened disciples he is giving them a hint about his divine nature.  Because… what—walking on water isn’t enough of a clue?   Sarcasm aside, I think those who want to see this wording as Jesus making a statement about his divine nature are reading too much into it because ego eimi is also exactly how one would say, “It’s me.”  So when the disciples cry out in fear, Jesus calls back to them and says, “Get a grip and calm down, guys.  It’s me.”

And this is where things get strange.  Well…stranger.  “Peter answered him, ‘Lord, if it is you, command me to come to you on the water.’” Oh Peter.  Peter, Peter, Peter.  What’s going on with you, man?  This challenge is so troubling on a number of levels.  First, “if it is you” sounds way too much like what the devil said to Jesus during the temptation in the wilderness: “If you really are the son of God…” (Matthew 4:3 and 4:8).  There is an echo there, is there not?  If it is you… If you really are…  It’s a challenge for Jesus to prove himself.   Second, Peter clearly has not thought this through.  If it is, indeed, a ghost or some malicious spirit, what’s to keep that entity from urging Peter to step out of the boat just so he can plunge to his death?  Whoopsie.  Finally, Peter’s challenge puts Jesus in a very awkward position.  “If it is you” creates a conundrum with no gracious exit.  If Jesus does not command Peter to come, to walk across the water to him, if he says, “No, Peter, don’t be an idiot” or even something gentler like “No Peter you’re not ready for that,” there will be a big question in the minds of the disciples about just who it is who is getting in the boat with them after walking across the water.  They might even try to prevent him from getting in the boat if they think he has failed the “if it is you” test.   Jesus is really left with only one option.

He said, “Come.”  

So Peter got out of the boat, started walking on the water, and came toward Jesus. But when he noticed the strong wind, he became frightened, and beginning to sink, he cried out, “Lord, save me!”  Jesus immediately reached out his hand and caught him, saying to him, “You of little faith, why did you doubt?”  When they got into the boat, the wind ceased.  And those in the boat worshiped him, saying, “Truly you are the Son of God.”

The traditional explanation of all this goes something like this:  when Jesus commands or asks us to do the impossible we can do it if we just have faith and keep our eyes on Jesus.  If we start to sink, Jesus will reach down and save us.  This explanation wraps the story in a nice, easily understood package suitable for church and personal use in any number of situations.  It also fits nicely with the recurring “you of little faith “ theme in Matthew.  Stepping out of the boat to take on a whopping financial obligation for a new building program?  Stepping out of the boat by quitting your job so you can start a new business?  Don’t let the winds bother you.  Keep your eyes on Jesus.  Keep your eyes on Jesus and everything will be okay.  “You of little faith, why did you doubt?”  

Keep your eyes on Jesus really is excellent advice in all circumstances always.  But when Jesus says, “you of little faith” what, exactly is he referring to?  Is he referring to Peter’s sudden, sinking fear when he realized that he was standing on turbulent water in a heavy wind without his floaties?   Or is he referring to Peter’s “if it is you” challenge, the doubt that initiated Peter’s perilous watery stroll that almost sank him? 

How many times in life do we get in trouble because we take on something nobody asked us to do?   Jesus ordered his disciples to get in the boat.  He never asked them to get out of it.  

Years ago, in the first parish where I served as pastor there was a man named Wayne who kept taking on jobs that nobody had asked him to do.  Wayne was a big, strong, retired older man who was always looking for ways to be of use to the church.  He was especially fond of gardening and, since he lived across the street from the church, he was on the church property puttering in the flower beds pretty much all the time.  This could have been a nice bonus for the congregation if Wayne had been half as knowledgeable as he thought he was and if he had paid even a little bit of attention to what the church property committee had spent many hours planning in terms of landscape design.

One day Wayne popped into my office to chat and found me sitting in the enclosed garden between my office and the sacristy.  He looked around the garden which, admittedly, was due for some attention, then said, “Pastor, why don’t you let me fix up this garden for you.  I can make it real nice.”   I thanked him for the offer but told him I already had plans for the garden, plans that had been approved by the Council and the Property Committee.  He asked me what I had in mind and I told him that I was going to plant some grapevines.  My plan was to plant some Syrah vines which I knew would do well there, then later have the Confirmation students harvest the grapes and make wine for communion.  It was also part of my plan for them to grind some wheat to make flour then bake bread for communion.  I had begun to plan a small communion curriculum around these experiences.  

I thought I had made it pretty clear to Wayne that I had a plan for that garden and I really didn’t want him to do anything with that space, so I was completely gobsmacked when I returned home from a continuing education retreat to discover that Wayne had planted grape vines in my office garden.  Specifically, he had planted table grapes.  Thompson Seedless grapes.  Which can’t be used for making wine because they don’t produce enough sugar.  Wayne was so proud and happy with what he had done that he couldn’t understand why the pastor and the council president and the property committee and the education committee were less than thrilled by his efforts.

How many times in life do we get in trouble because we take on something nobody asked us to do?   Jesus ordered his disciples to get in the boat.  He never asked anybody to get out of it.  

Image: The Hand of God by Yongsung Kim

Nothin’ Ain’t Nothin’

There’s no such thing as nothing.

Matthew 14:13-21

In this Sunday’s gospel reading Jesus feeds more than 5000 people with five loaves and two fish, so of course I’ve been thinking about quantum mechanics.  Bear with me here.

There are six accounts in the gospels of Jesus feeding multitudes of people from almost nothing: two accounts in Matthew, two in Mark, one in Luke and one in John.  The stories are similar in most details.  In each one Jesus is moved by compassion for the crowd and uses the very meager resources at hand—five loaves and two fish in some accounts or seven loaves and a few fish in others—to provide so much food that baskets of leftovers are collected afterward.  In the synoptic versions the initial loaves and fishes are something the disciples already have on hand, but in John’s version, the loaves and fish are provided by a young boy who has been watching Jesus from the edge of the crowd.  

This miracle story was clearly an important event in the memory of the early church which may be why there are six versions of it.  Of course, it’s also entirely possible that Jesus really did feed multitudes on multiple occasions.  It would be such a Jesus thing to do.

It’s very tempting to try to find ways to rationally explain the miracles of Jesus, especially the miracle of feeding a multitude with such obviously inadequate resources, but if we go wandering down that rabbit hole we’re bound to miss something important.  Some think that the people in the crowd were so inspired by seeing Jesus and the disciples passing out their measly 5 loaves and two fish that they all decided to share the snacks they had stashed away in their sleeves.  Sure.  That works.  Maybe.  I suppose it would be a small miracle in its own way and certainly a good example of sharing what you have to make sure everyone has something.  But the Gospel writers don’t even hint that that’s what was happening in these accounts.  They seem to think that something much more impressive happened. 

I, for one, have no problem believing that Jesus made food appear where none had been before.  After all, God has been creating something out of nothing since the beginning of . . . everything.  

“Nothing” seems to be God’s favorite material to work with.  Nature abhors a vacuum.  Emptiness is meant to be filled.  And nothing is not nothing—it’s always chock full of potential.  

Here’s what the science says:  In quantum mechanics, absolute nothingness cannot exist because empty space is filled with zero-point energy.  That means that the lowest possible energy state still holds a baseline of irreducible energy and movement that cannot be removed.  Even in a vacuum there are fluctuations of energy because “empty” space is actually filled with active quantum fields.  In other words, “Nothing” is actually full of Something and that Something is Possibilities.  In quantum mechanics, “Nothing” has the potential to be Anything.  Loaves and fishes, for instance.

So, was Jesus manipulating quantum fields to feed the multitude or was something else going on?  We’ll probably never know.  And is there really any point in figuring it out?  I think we lose something if we try too hard to demystify the mystery.  Plus, the whole point of the story is that Jesus found himself surrounded by hungry people so he fed them.  More specifically, he had the disciples feed them.

There are a lot of similarities in the 6 miracle feeding stories, but the context for each one is different, and the context is particularly important in Matthew 14, so let’s go back to the beginning.

When the disciples of John the Baptist came to tell Jesus that John had been murdered by Herod Antipas, Jesus “withdrew from there in a boat to a deserted place by himself.”  It’s easy to imagine that Jesus wanted some privacy for his grief, some time to pray, some time to think about what this meant for the message of the kingdom of heaven that both he and John had been proclaiming.  But when he got to that lonely spot at the end of the lake, instead of a private retreat there was a multitude waiting for him.

When the crowds heard that John had been killed, they went looking for Jesus.  John had been important to them, and if anyone could speak to their fear, their loss, their broken hearts and their shattered hopes, it would be Jesus.  “They followed him on foot from the towns.  When he went ashore, he saw a great crowd; and he had compassion for them and cured their sick.”

When Jesus saw the crowd, in spite of his own fatigue and sorrow, he went to work.  He prayed.  He laid hands on the sick.  He hollowed himself out so all the power of the Holy Spirit could flow through him.  

And he let himself feel their hunger.  Spiritual hunger.  Intellectual hunger.  Hunger for a better life.  Hunger for justice.  Hunger for independence. Hunger for healing.  And just plain, old physical hunger for food.  He felt all of it.  From all of them.  A great chasm of hunger from the thousands on the hillside in front of him.

Standing in the vortex of all their hunger he loved them, and his compassion moved him to do the impossible.  He took what he had, five loaves and two fish, which by every worldly measure was obviously insufficient, then he looked up to heaven, and he blessed it.  Eulogesen is the Greek word in Matthew’s text.  It quite literally means that he said good things about it.  “Thank you.  This is good.”  Then he broke the bread and told his disciples, his students, to hand it out to the crowd, trusting that in this God-made, God-blessed world, on that God-blessed hillside with all its God-blessed hunger what they had to share was good, and that by God’s power and presence and grace there would be enough.  More than enough.

“And all ate and were filled,” Matthew tells us, “and they took up what was left over of the broken pieces, twelve baskets full. And those who ate were about five thousand men, besides women and children.”

Jesus fed five thousand men, besides women and children—such a weird way for Matthew to tell us that there were whole families there on that hillside but women and children were not included in the head count.  Jesus fed all those people from five loaves and two fish, but the food that fed them wasn’t the only thing that Jesus created out of almost nothing that day.  He also created a community.  A community of companionship.

Meals were not merely utilitarian in first century Palestine.  Sharing a meal was a way to affirm kinship, friendship and good will. Sharing a meal was also a way to affirm or elevate one’s status in a world where status was important.  To put it plainly, it was a way to show that those gathered together for the meal recognized each other as “acceptable” in a world where all too often some were regarded as “unacceptable” or “unclean.” 

Jesus, had been criticized by some Pharisees for eating with “sinners” and tax collectors, people considered unacceptable in good company.  But in this feast on the hillside at the end of the lake, he included everyone, regardless of their social standing or ritual acceptability.  In that great crowd of all kinds of people, no one was turned away.  No one was excluded.  Everyone was equal in their hunger.  Everyone was equal in being fed.

In the book After Jesus Before Christianity, the authors tell us that meals were the primary social engagement for the early followers of Jesus.  During the first two centuries, the people who were loyal to Jesus commonly organized themselves into something that would look like supper clubs to us.  They would gather once, twice or even several times a week in someone’s home to share a meal, to sing, to pray together and to remember the stories of Jesus. 

In an era when the Church is in decline, I can’t help but wonder what might happen if we followed the example of those early Jesus people today.  What would happen if we transformed our pews into long tables and benches and converted our sanctuaries into dining halls then gathered each week to throw open our doors and invite our neighbors in for a hearty meal, some prayer and some singing?   Who knows what kinds of hunger we might feed?  Who knows what kind of emptiness Christ might fill?

In a world where 645 million people will go hungry today[1]—48 million[2] of them in our own country—in a world where 45% of all child deaths are caused by hunger or hunger-related illness, these stories of Jesus feeding multitudes serve to remind us that we have a responsibility to feed a hungry world and we’re not doing a very good job of following his example.  

Hunger in our world and in our country is a solvable problem.  The US Department of Agriculture estimates that 120 to 160 billion pounds of food is wasted every year in this country alone—that’s 20 to 40% of the entire US food supply being dumped into landfills while 48 million people go hungry.  

Each of the Miraculous feeding stories begins by telling us that Jesus was moved by compassion for the hungry crowd, and I can’t help but think that maybe that’s the thing we’re missing when it comes to feeding our hungry world.  When grain shipments bound for food-insecure nations are blown up at the dock by the misguided missiles of a needless war, it’s hard to believe that food production is the problem.  When voices in Congress are trying to reduce or eliminate the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, also known as food stamps, it’s hard to believe that inflation of food prices is the main reason people are going hungry.  When 67 counties in our country are food deserts that don’t have a single grocery store because the big grocery corporations decided that a supermarket in those counties would not be profitable, it’s hard to believe that the high rate of food insufficiency in those same 67 counties is because people are uninformed about the importance of healthy nutrition.  When the Orange County Register reports that hunger in supposedly affluent Orange County, California, a county with 58 million-dollar zip codes, is worse now than in the Great Recession of 2008[3], it’s a sign that something is seriously out of balance in our nation, our culture and our world.

The six gospel accounts of Jesus feeding thousands of hungry people are a clear invitation for us to consider how we are or are not following his example in feeding hungry people today.  Remember, after Jesus blesses the loaves and fish he hands them back to the disciples and says, “You feed them.”

Those of us who come to church come with hungers of our own.  We also come to share a meal— a meal that reminds us that we are in Christ and Christ is in us—a meal that fills us with Christ’s compassion as we taste and see the goodness of the Lord.  We come to share a meal that calls us to trust that in this God-made, God-blessed world, that in this God-blessed place with all its God-blessed hungers what we have is good.  We come to learn again that we can share what we have even when it doesn’t seem to be enough, and that by God’s power and presence there will always be enough.  More than enough. 


[1] https://ipes-food.org/un-hunger-report-2026-global-hunger-remains-stubbornly-high-as-another-food-price-crisis-looms

[2]  https://www.feedingamerica.org/hunger-in-america

[3] ANDRE MOUCHARD | amouchard@scng.com | Orange County Register

PUBLISHED: July 30, 2026 at 5:21 PM PDT | UPDATED: July 31, 2026 at 6:45 AM PDT

Matthew’s String of Pearls

The kingdom of heaven is….organic.

Matthew 13:31-51

From the very beginning of his ministry, the preaching and teaching of Jesus was centered on and anchored in one single, clear message:  “The time is ripe.  The Reign of God is arriving.  Change your life and trust the good news.”[1]   

Ever since Constantine this message has too often been either spiritualized or relegated to end times theology.  We forget that Jesus was actually delivering a radically subversive message in Roman occupied Galilee.  He really was committed to replacing the oppressive and violently enforced governance of the Roman empire—and all empires forever after—with the commonwealth of God’s justice and kindness.  He wanted people to understand, though, that it isn’t enough just to change governments or economic systems.  What he was aiming for—and is still aiming for—is a transformation of human persons and human society, a radical renovation of values and vision, a sea change in the collective human soul.  

Jesus wanted people to understand that he was not trying to raise a rebel army or initiate a political revolt because the kingdom of heaven, as Matthew calls it, would not be imposed on anyone.  God’s dominion does not arrive through military conquest or rebellion or heavy-handed politics.  Instead, it grows and spreads slowly, organically, until it has quietly amended everyone’s expectations and values while almost invisibly transforming the way the world operates.  This organic development of the kingdom, by the way, stands in stark opposition to the fever dream of Christian Nationalism.

In chapter 13 of Matthew, Jesus shares a series of parables, a string of pearls to help illustrate how the reign of God will softly supplant the iron grip of empire.  Since so much of what Jesus was teaching was about envisioning a whole new way of life with very different values, he wanted people to spend time with the ideas he was sharing.  So he gave them parables that hinted at his deeper message—stories that they could carry away with them so that they could feel some ownership of the vision when they worked out the riddles for themselves.

In the Parable of the Sower, the Sower spreads “the word of the kingdom”[2] everywhere with no regard for where it lands.  A lot of people don’t get it or can’t be bothered.  Some receive it but can’t hold on to it.  But some take it in and it takes root in their hearts, minds and imaginations until it becomes their reality.

In the parable of the Wheat and the Weeds, Jesus reminds his followers that all the goodness of God’s dominion is going to be growing up side-by-side and surrounded by all the toxic evil of the world.  Why?  Because there are forces in the world that are hostile to God’s vision of how life should be.  He cautions us that evil often mimics good and we can’t always tell the difference, so we shouldn’t be too eager to rush in and eliminate what we think is evil in the name of purity.

Following the Parable of the Wheat and the Weeds, Jesus gives us six rapid-fire parables in a row in the space of 20 short verses: the parable of the Mustard Seed, the Parable of the Yeast (which is really sourdough starter, but we’ll get to that in a moment), the Parable of the Treasure in the Field, the Parable of the Pearl Merchant, the Parable of the Fish in the Net, and the Parable of the Old and New.

At the end of all these parables Jesus asks his disciples, “Have you understood all this?”  The word we translate as “understood,” syniemi , has a layered meaning in Greek.  It means to put it all together, to assemble, to assimilate.  

Have you understood all this?   Are you putting it all together?

So if we really want to understand the parable of the fish in the nets—to put it all together—it helps if we have a handle on the mustard seed.  So with that in mind, let’s start at the end of this string of parables and work our way back to the beginning.

“Every scribe who has been discipled for the kingdom of heaven is like the master of a household who brings out of his treasure what is new and what is old.”[3]  In The Message, Eugene Peterson put it this way: “Every student well-trained in God’s kingdom is like the owner of a general store who can put his hands on anything you need, old or new, exactly when you need it.”  I think that captures the point pretty well.  

We’ve all known people who are so devoted to the old way of doing things, the old ideas, the old songs, the old way we’ve always done it—whatever it is—that they just can’t or won’t adjust to anything new or different.  On the other side of the coin we’ve all known people who are so enamored with the new that they have no patience or tolerance with the old tried and true.  “Hold on,” says Jesus.  “A well-trained disciple for the Empire of Heaven will have a good battery-powered drill, but Grandpa’s trusty hammer, wrenches and screw drivers will also be in his tool kit.”  Followers of Jesus in the commonwealth of God’s justice and kindness need a variety of tools to reach people with God’s love and generosity.   

Reading this parable again, though, I find it intriguing that this parable begins with “Every scribe” and I can’t help but think that the writer of Matthew may be describing himself here.  We know that the author was a fairly accomplished scribe.  He had to be to write a work of this length.  We know that he was using a copy of the Gospel of Mark since he pretty much follows Mark’s order of events and there are places where Mark’s wording is copied verbatim in Matthew.  So, is the Gospel of Mark the “new” referred to here?  We also know that Matthew, the writer, is very familiar with the Hebrew Bible.  Is that the “old?”  Matthew’s gospel, in and of itself, gives us a good example of a well-discipled scribe for the kingdom of heaven who is bringing out of his treasure something old and something new.

“Again, the kingdom of heaven is like a net that was thrown into the sea and caught fish of every kind.  When it was full, they drew it ashore, sat down, and put the good into baskets but threw out the bad. So it will be at the end of the age. The angels will come out and separate the evil from the righteous.”[4]   

This isn’t just any old net in this parable, it’s a sagéne, a long dragnet that was often pulled between two boats.  It is like the reign of God in that it catches fish of every kind.  It’s a very inclusive net.  The Empire of Heaven includes everyone.  There is no purity test for us to apply because the righteous fish are swimming right alongside the “bad” fish.  Like the Weeds among the Wheat the bad is mixed in with the good.  But that’s not our problem.  It’s not our job to do the sorting.  Angels will take care of it when the time comes.

“Again, the kingdom of heaven is like a merchant in search of fine pearls; on finding one pearl of great value, he went and sold all that he had and bought it.”[5]

This parable may have been a bit shocking for the people originally hearing Jesus teach on the shore of Galilee or to those originally reading in Mattew’s gospel.  The “merchant” is a wholesaler, an emporo, in the Greek.  People in this business were not respected in Jesus’ time; they were regarded as decadent because they traveled a lot and associated with all kinds of people.  They also tended to be comparatively wealthy which made them suspect since making money meant that someone else was parting with money.  We know that this particular emporo in the parable had to be quite rich because he was wholesaling pearls which, in the first century world, were the most valuable and rarest of all gems.  This wholesaler is used to dealing with pearls.  He sees them all the time.  But unexpectedly, one uniquely beautiful pearl so captivates him that he feels he must possess it.  He gets out of the wholesaling business.  He liquidates his inventory so he can afford to buy this one very special pearl.  He trades the many for the one.  It transform him.  He becomes a buyer instead of a trader.  He has found the thing he had never realized he was searching for all along.  The domain of heaven is like that.

“The kingdom of heaven is like a treasure hidden in a field.”[6]  A man taking a shortcut across the field stumbles across it.  When he realizes what he has found, he hides it again.  He doesn’t want to lose it to someone else.  He sells everything he has to buy the field but he’s not really interested in the field.  He wants what’s in the field.  Hidden.  Buried.  Get it?  God’s realm of justice and kindness is like that.  It’s the unexpected discovery that makes life immeasurably richer, enlarges joy, and changes everything.  

He told them another parable: “The kingdom of heaven is like yeast that a woman took and mixed in with three measures of flour until all of it was leavened.”[7]

I have a pet peeve with our English translations of this parable.  First, it’s not yeast.  Nobody knew about yeast as a distinctive organism until Anton van Leeuwenhoek observed yeast cells under the microscope in 1680, and even then he didn’t know what it was he was seeing.  What the original text says is that the kingdom of heaven is like leaven.  Zumei is the Greek word.  Think of it like sourdough starter.  Also, the woman doesn’t mix it into the flour.  She hides it in the flour.  She conceals it.  Enekrypsen is the Greek word.  Like cryptic.  So again, the commonwealth of God’s love and generosity is a thing that is definitely there but hidden from casual observation.  It’s also worth noting that the three measures of flour described here is a very large amount of flour—forty to sixty pounds of flour.  This little pinch of leaven is going to produce a lot of bread. 

Leaven was well known in ancient Israel and used year round except during Passover.  It had to be eliminated from the house during Passover because it was considered an impurity.  Plutarch described it as “the product of corruption.”  Leaven is actually a small amount of cultured mold.  And yet Jesus tells us that the kingdom of heaven is like that.  A little bit of something that some think is impure hidden in the midst of everything desirable… and this little bit of impurity transforms all the good “pure” flour.  It makes it rise.  It gives it that wonderful baked bread flavor and aroma.  The kingdom of heaven is like that.

He put before them another parable: “The kingdom of heaven is like a mustard seed that someone took and sowed in his field; it is the smallest of all the seeds, but when it has grown it is the greatest of shrubs and becomes a tree, so that the birds of the air come and make nests in its branches.”[8]

So, a small thing becomes a big thing… is that what this parable is all about?  Well, yes and no.  Mustard was and is an incredibly useful plant but it self-propagates so it takes a bit of work to keep it from taking over a field or garden.  Mustard seeds were ground like peppercorns and used to season food or make condiments.  The Gospel of Mark says it grows to become the greatest of all vegetables.  It’s leaves and roots are edible and there have been more than a few times in history where wild mustard plants saved people from starvation during a time of famine.  Farmers in Galilee and Judea would plant rows of mustard next to their crops to keep grazing animals like sheep, goats and cows out of their fields because the animals didn’t like the pungent taste or smell of the mustard plant.   It really can grow to the size of a small tree if it’s not trimmed back.  Sparrows and finches really do shelter in its branches and feed on its seeds, and it provides shade where any number of small creatures can escape from the heat.  So yes.  The kingdom of heaven is like that.  

Have you understood all this?   Are you putting the pieces together? Can you take these images with you and see where the seed is sprouting and the dough is rising?  

Maybe you’ll stumble across a remarkable treasure in a place where you would never dream such a thing or person or idea or insight could be.  Maybe one afternoon in the middle of something utterly familiar you’ll suddenly be completely captivated by something exquisitely beautiful that transcends everything else you’re accustomed to.

Have you understood all this?  Are you putting the pieces together?

Take your time.  Take these little stories home with you.  Let them percolate.  Every student who is in training for the commonwealth of God’s justice and kindness is like a good handyman who carries in his toolkit some of the newest and best but also some of the old tried and true.  Get the picture?


[1] Mark 1:15, my translation.  See also Matthew 4:23

[2] Matthew 13:19

[3] Matthew 13:52

[4] Matthew 13:47-48

[5] 13:45-46

[6] 13:44

[7] 13:33

[8] 13:31-32